Comparing Different Types of Fly Screens: Which is Right for You?

Flies, mosquitos, and other insects are as much a part of summer as barbecues, swimming pools, and family get-togethers.

Maintaining a comfortable and pest-free home environment is essential in today’s world. Installing fly screens is one of the most effective ways to achieve this. These screens are necessary for keeping insects, such as mosquitoes and flies, out of your living spaces while allowing fresh air to circulate. This blog will compare different types of fly screens—pleated, retractable, and fixed—to help you decide which is best suited for your needs.

Understanding Fly Screens

What are Fly Screens?

Fly screens, also known as insect screens, are a wonderful addition to windows and doors to prevent bugs from entering while allowing full airflow. They consist of mesh barriers that cover the full opening and come in different types, colours, and finishes. They play a crucial role in home comfort and health by reducing the risk of insect-borne diseases and ensuring a pleasant living environment.

Importance in Home Comfort and Health

Fly screens are not just a convenience to avoid getting annoyed by buzzing flying pests but also help you keep a healthy home. Many insects are responsible for diseases like West Nile virus, so keeping them out of your home keeps you and your loved ones safe while allowing fresh air to circulate.

Types of Fly Screens

As mentioned above, there are many different types of fly screens available, so let’s have a look at the most common ones.

Pleated Fly Screens

Pleated fly screens feature a concertina-like structure that folds away when not in use, like an accordion. They are typically made of durable mesh and can be installed on doors and windows.

Advantages

• Flexibility: Pleated screens can cover large openings, making them ideal for sliding doors and large windows.
• Ease of Use: They are easy to operate, often requiring just a gentle push or pull.
• Aesthetic Appeal: Their sleek design adds a modern touch to any home.

Disadvantages

• Durability Issues: The pleated design may be more susceptible to wear and tear over time.
• Higher Cost: They are generally more expensive than other fly screens.

Pleated fly screens are perfect for large openings like sliding doors and expansive windows. They can be stored compactly when not in use, making them a convenient option.

Retractable Fly Screens

Not unlike pleated fly screens, retractable fly screens can be rolled up into a cassette when not in use. They are often installed vertically for windows or horizontally for doors and also are a flexible and compact option.

Advantages

• Versatility: They can be used on various window and door types.
• Space-Saving: When not in use, they retract entirely out of sight.
• Unobtrusive: Their discrete design ensures they don’t interfere with the overall aesthetics of your home.

Disadvantages

• Higher Initial Cost: They are more expensive to purchase and install.
• Potential Mechanical Issues: The retractable mechanism may require occasional maintenance.

Retractable fly screens are ideal for frequently used doors and windows. They offer the full benefits of keeping insects and other pests from entering your home but tuck away unobtrusively when not in use or when you don’t have your windows and doors open, allowing full natural light into your home.

Fixed Fly Screens

Fixed fly screens are the traditional type of fly screen that most people are used to in their homes. They are usually made of sturdy mesh and are permanently attached to window or door frames unless you remove them altogether.

Advantages

• Cost-Effective: Generally, they are the least expensive type of fly screen.
• Durable: Their fixed nature makes them robust and long-lasting.
• Low Maintenance: Once installed, they require minimal upkeep.

Disadvantages

• Less Flexibility: They cannot be removed or adjusted easily.
• Permanent Installation: This can be a drawback if you want the option to open the window entirely.

Fixed fly screens are ideal for rarely opened windows and high-traffic areas where a permanent solution is needed.

Comparison of Fly Screens

Material and Durability

Pleated fly screens are typically made from polyester or polypropylene mesh to give them flexibility. These screens are durable but may wear out quicker due to their folding mechanism. On the other hand, retractable fly screens are often constructed with high-quality fibreglass or polyester mesh, offering good durability but requiring periodic maintenance to ensure the retractable system functions smoothly. Fixed fly screens are commonly made from sturdy materials like aluminum or fibreglass mesh. These materials make the screens highly durable and can withstand prolonged exposure to the elements.

Cost Analysis

Like with many investments, cost can play a significant role, especially if you have multiple screens to install. When looking at the initial costs, fixed screens are the most affordable option due to their permanent installation without moving parts. Pleated and retractable screens come at higher costs due to their more complex designs and materials.

In the long term, fixed screens also have the lowest maintenance cost as you only have to clean them occasionally. Pleated fly screens will require moderate maintenance for cleaning and potential repairs as the wear and tear is higher. Retractable screens may incur higher maintenance costs due to the mechanical components.

Ease of Installation

When looking at the installation, the three types of fly screens come with very different requirements.

• Pleated Fly Screens: Typically require professional installation due to their complexity, though some DIY kits are available.
• Retractable Fly Screens: Best installed by professionals to ensure the retractable mechanism is correctly set up, though experienced DIY enthusiasts can also handle the installation.
• Fixed Fly Screens: The easiest to install, often suitable for DIY projects, but professional installation can ensure a perfect fit.

Aesthetic and Design Considerations

With all three types, your design preference may also influence your decision. Where fixed fly screens can be customized in different colours and frame materials to match your home, pleated versions are also available but usually blend best with a more modern home design. With retractable fly screens, the primary design consideration is that they are made to be unobtrusive, so if you want an option that doesn’t actually affect your home’s aesthetic, they can be an excellent choice.

Choosing the Right Fly Screen for Your Needs

When shopping for fly screens, there are a few factors to consider. First off, assess your needs.

When choosing a fly screen, consider the following factors:

• Location: Determine where the screens will be installed—windows, doors, or both.
  • Large Openings and Sliding Doors: Pleated fly screens are the best option due to their flexibility and aesthetic appeal.
  • Frequently Used Doors and Windows: Retractable fly screens provide convenience and unobtrusiveness.
  • Rarely Opened Windows and High-Traffic Areas: Fixed fly screens offer a durable and cost-effective solution.
• Frequency of Use: Consider how often you will open the windows or doors.
• Budget: Factor in both initial and long-term costs.

Conclusion

When choosing the right fly screen, a lot depends on your specific needs, such as how often you must open the window or door, whether you are looking for a versatile and discreet design and your budget. This will allow you to get the optimal insect and pest protection for your home and ensure ventilation without having to worry about insects or other pests.

Pleated Fly Screens is a leading company that offers a wide range of high-quality and reliable pleated fly screen services. Our services are designed to protect your home or business from pesky insects while creating a comfortable and healthy indoor environment. With over 20 years of experience, we are focused on high quality, whether in materials, installation, or customer service.

Our experienced experts are ready to help you find the perfect screen for your windows and doors! Call today at 866-674-0946 or complete our convenient online form!